• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Purchase photos
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Itemlive

Itemlive

North Shore news powered by The Daily Item

  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
  • Police/Fire
  • Government
  • Obituaries
  • Archives
  • E-Edition
  • Help
Marblehead native and St. John's Prep receiver Riley Selvais reaches for an overthrown pass. (Leanna Puccio) Purchase this photo

St. John’s Prep fights, falls in Super Bowl as Xaverian three-peats

Joey Barrett

December 6, 2025 by Joey Barrett

FOXBOROUGH — Not once, but twice did St. John’s Prep have a golden chance to get the ball back and drive downfield for the game-winning touchdown at Gillette Stadium Saturday night.

But as the clock ticked away and student sections roared, Xaverian’s offense had other plans.

Hawks’ quarterback Will Wood — clutch as ever — converted a third-down screen pass before taking one himself on fourth down in the final minutes. The right-handed gunslinger remained cool, calm, and collected as No. 3 Xaverian (11-2) captured the Division 1 Super Bowl 41-35 against top-ranked St. John’s Prep (11-2).

It was Xaverian’s third consecutive Super Bowl win and second in three years against its archrival. The 2023 version of Prep-Xaverian also finished a six-point game.

Wood stole the show, tossing five touchdowns and 345 yards. His five TDs tied Kyle Beatrice’s (Swampscott) all-time MIAA Super Bowl record.

Speaking of records, teammate and receiver Dave Chiavegato hauled in three of those touchdown passes to tie another Super Bowl record.

St. John’s, which last won the big game in 2022, nearly stole another after trailing by three scores in the fourth quarter. Quarterback Chris Vargas connected with wideout Ethan Stefanovich for the final two scores of the game, but some late first downs helped Xaverian kneel out the clock.

Xaverian’s 27-7 halftime cushion was too big a hole — no matter the size of Prep’s second-half shovel.

Marblehead native Riley Selvais (3 catches, 81 yards receiving) tied the game 7-7 when he caught a 48-yard touchdown pass in the opening quarter. Rising to the occasion as a sophomore, he also returned a second-half kick 80 yards to the house.

Jordan Toribio (87 yards rushing, TD) and Maxwell Parent (37 yards rushing) led Prep’s ground attack, while Vargas — back from injury — was 10-of-25 for 217 yards with three touchdowns and two interceptions.

Other than the two turnovers, you could say St. John’s played a clean game with just three penalties, 15 first downs, and 339 yards of offense. That said, the Eagles were 0-for-6 on third down and 0-2 on fourth.

The Prep (6-6 all-time in Super Bowls) took down No. 16 Framingham, No. 8 Leominster, and No. 5 Central Catholic in the state tournament. Xaverian handed St. John’s its first loss of the season on Thanksgiving Day.

  • Joey Barrett

    Joey Barrett is the Daily Item's Sports Editor. He reports on local high schools, colleges, and professional teams. Prior to his current position, he worked for UMass Athletics, the Cape Cod Baseball League, and Gannett Media, among others. Barrett was also Sports Editor at Endicott College and treasurer of Endicott's Society of Professional Journalists branch.

    View all posts

Related posts:

Gillette hosting MIAA football championships this week High school football predictions (Div. 1 Super Bowl) MIAA BRACKETS: Local football teams eye state tournament runs Furious last-ditch effort by St. John’s Prep falls short

Primary Sidebar

Advertisement

Sponsored Content

Financial advice for U.S. Citizens in Spain

Safe, Supervised, and Grounded in Care: How Lumin Health Delivers Ketamine Therapy Responsibly

Revenge Saving: Taking Back Control of Your Finances – with a Little Help from Beverly Credit Union

Advertisement

Upcoming Events

38 SPECIAL

December 13, 2025
Lynn Auditorium

4th Annual LCTV & CCoL Photos with Santa & Toy Drive

December 11, 2025
181 Union Street, Lynn, MA, United States, Massachusetts 01901

Adult Book Club: Bring a Book to Share

December 17, 2025
Lynn Public Library

Adult Color/Paint Time

December 13, 2025
5 N Common St, Lynn, MA, United States, Massachusetts 01902

Footer

About Us

  • About Us
  • Editorial Practices
  • Advertising and Sponsored Content

Reader Services

  • Subscribe
  • Manage Your Subscription
  • Activate Subscriber Account
  • Submit an Obituary
  • Submit a Classified Ad
  • Daily Item Photo Store
  • Submit A Tip
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions

Essex Media Group Publications

  • La Voz
  • Lynnfield Weekly News
  • Marblehead Weekly News
  • Peabody Weekly News
  • 01907 The Magazine
  • 01940 The Magazine
  • 01945 The Magazine
  • North Shore Golf Magazine

© 2025 Essex Media Group